diff options
Diffstat (limited to '')
| -rw-r--r-- | remarks/WR-026.txt | 87 |
1 files changed, 87 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/remarks/WR-026.txt b/remarks/WR-026.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1ee1fe7 --- /dev/null +++ b/remarks/WR-026.txt @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ + + + + + + + +Document: WR-026 P. Webb + 2026.07.23 + + On Codeberg banning crypto and LLM-assisted repos + +Body + + The great thing about the internet is that other people have the same + thoughts as you, saving you from typing your own novel. Case in + point[1]: + + > It’s frankly a bit snotty of _Codeberg_ to make this argument at + > all, considering that the platform effectively lives inside the + > _Forgejo_ bubble, and _Forgejo_ ~~mutinied~~ _inherited_ its + > community of active contributors from _Gitea_, who had spent the + > better part of six years building that community before _Forgejo_ + > even existed. A project that acquired its own community by + > hard-forking someone else’s, then turned around to lecture solo + > developers about not having one, is a difficult position to argue + > from with a straight face. + > + > In addition, _Codeberg_ conflates _“having a community”_ with + > _“being legitimate software worth hosting”_, when the bar for a + > personal project has always been a working build, ideally a + > license, and maybe a README, and not a channel full of + > contributors. A good deal of what makes the small, single-author + > tool ecosystem worth having is precisely that it doesn’t need a + > community to justify its existence, and a forge whose entire + > selling point is hosting the code of individuals is an odd place to + > argue the opposite. + + and[2]: + + > I'm sure you have some morally high reasons to stand against + > cryptocurrency, but the "illicit trade" and "evasion of sanctions" + > cited by sourcehut (since you seem to base your decision on it) are + > also what allows regular people, including LGBTQ+ people, living in + > sanctioned countries (which also, what a surprise, turn out to be + > unsafe for LGBTQ+ folk a lot of the time), to buy goods and + > send/receive money from abroad without being prosecuted by their + > governments (hi foreign agent laws! hi "extremism" and + > "terrorism" laws!). + > + > I'm sorry, anti-war transgender person stuck in Russia, but from + > our moral stance, you shouldn't be able to purchase HRT from a lab + > using your XMR wallet. nor should your friend be able to pay for + > their foreign VPN VDS that they use to bypass the internet + > restrictions in USDT. the projects you used for this were hosted on + > Codeberg and not some other platform? well, too bad, they'll have + > to go someplace else that minds your existence or is welcoming to + > cryptocurrency as a whole, and you will wait. you and the tools you + > use will move to a greedy corporate hosting that is likely to + > impose its own restrictions on you in the future, or, even better, + > move to a less reliable self-hosted option, one per each tool to + > make it less maintainable and less accessible. + > + > by taking this stance, at least from my perspective, you're just + > projecting your morally high delusion of dirty illicit 3rd world + > crypto scammers that are damaging the moral purity of Codeberg + > by... hosting code for their projects here?! which, mind you, + > almost all the time will just contain tools, _tools_ to do good or + > bad. do you want to ban BitTorrent-related projects from Codeberg + > next because they are "mostly used to get illegal access to + > unlicensed digital goods and services (piracy)" and also take up + > world bandwidth and compute? how about banning YouTube downloaders + > after those? hey, let's make it clear that Codeberg will not stand + > a single repo on its platform that involves encrypted messaging: + > you know only criminals use Matrix, right? + + finally, from your's truly[3]: + + > They really quoted the FBI Director in their reasoning? Unserious + > people. Anything law enforcement can’t peek into is “designed + > for criminals.” + +References + + [1] <https://マリウス.com/i-regret-migrating-to-codeberg> + [2] <https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/pulls/1254#issuecomment-19918579> + [3] <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49021315> |